Chapter 3 - At my sister’s Charleston wedding, my parents called...
At eleven o'clock that morning, I was sitting in the sunlit parlor of my Broad Street townhome, reviewing the First Palmetto Bank loan covenants, when the brass knocker slammed twice against my front door.
My housekeeper, Mrs. Gable, stepped into the doorway looking startled. "Ms. Bennett, your sister is on the front stoop. She looks like she’s been crying all morning."
I closed my laptop slowly. "Let her in, Mrs. Gable. And please bring a pot of chamomile tea."
Victoria walked into the parlor ten seconds later, still wearing yesterday’s silk reception dress, her mascara smudged beneath red-rimmed eyes and her blonde hair pinned haphazardly off her neck.
She stopped three feet inside the room, her gaze sweeping over the original crown molding, the oil paintings, and the custom bookshelves before landing on me.
"You live here?" Victoria whispered, her voice cracking. "This is the old Pinckney townhome. It sold for four million dollars three years ago."
"Four point two," I said evenly, gesturing toward the armchair across from me. "Sit down, Victoria. You look like you’re about to collapse."
She didn't sit. Her hands trembled at her sides as she stared at me like she was trying to reconcile two completely different people.
"Andrew left this morning," she said, a tear spilling down her cheek. "He packed a suitcase, told me he needed space to think, and went back to Savannah with his parents."
"I'm sorry your honeymoon didn't happen," I said honestly. "Andrew seemed like a decent man yesterday."
"Don't pretend you care!" Victoria burst out, taking a sharp step forward. "You stood up in front of everyone we know and called Dad a thief! The Post and Courier just put his name on their front page!"
"Because he took $740,000 from a public charity," I said, keeping my voice calm and low. "I didn't write the article, Victoria, and I didn't forge his signature on those wire transfers."
"He told me it was a temporary bridge loan!" she cried, sinking suddenly onto the edge of the armchair as her knees gave out. "He said the condo pre-sales were closing next month and he was going to put every penny back before anyone noticed!"
"There are no condo pre-sales," I said quietly. "Harborview has been stalled at forty percent framing since October because Dad stopped paying the structural contractors."
Victoria stared at me, the color draining from her face. "What are you talking about? Dad told me the penthouse units were already reserved."
I reached across the coffee table, picked up the partnership summary Arthur Sullivan had given me at breakfast, and held it out to her.
"Do you recognize this document?"
Victoria took the sheet with shaking fingers, squinting at the dense print before her eyes dropped to the bottom line.
"That's... that's my signature," she stammered. "Dad had me sign this at the country club in January. He said it was just a tax form so he could put my wedding trust in my name."
"It's not a tax form, Victoria. It makes you a twenty-five percent managing member of Whitmore Development Group, complete with joint and several liability on a $14.2 million bank loan."
The paper slipped from her fingers and fluttered onto the rug.
"No," she breathed, shaking her head violently. "No, Dad wouldn't do that to me. I’m his favorite. He wouldn't put my name on a bad loan."
"He needed a co-guarantor with clean credit because his own credit line was maxed out," I said without anger. "And tomorrow morning, when First Palmetto Bank sees that the Attorney General is investigating him for charity fraud, they’re going to call the entire note due immediately."
Victoria covered her mouth with both hands, a choked sob escaping her throat. "I don't have fourteen million dollars, Emily. I don't even have fifty thousand dollars. My checking account only has eight thousand in it!"
Mrs. Gable quietly set the silver tea tray on the table and slipped out of the room, pulling the pocket doors shut behind her.
I poured a cup of chamomile tea and pushed it across the glass surface toward my sister.
"Drink that," I said. "Panicking isn't going to keep the bank from freezing your accounts on Tuesday."
Victoria wrapped both hands around the warm cup, staring down at the steam. For the first time in her life, the smug certainty that had armored her since childhood was completely gone.
"Why didn't you ever tell us?" she whispered, her voice barely audible. "About your firm. About this house. About the church."
"Because every time I opened my mouth around you and Mom and Dad, you told me I was an embarrassment," I said simply. "Eventually, you stop trying to prove your worth to people who have already decided you don't have any."
Victoria flinched as if I had slapped her. A fresh wave of tears spilled over her lashes, dripping onto her ruined silk dress.
"I was awful to you," she choked out. "Yesterday, in the church, when Dad pointed at you... I laughed. I actually laughed at you in front of Andrew’s family."
"Yes," I said softly. "You did."
"I don't deserve your help," she whispered, looking up at me with swollen, desperate eyes. "I know I don't. You have every right to let the bank take everything I own."
I looked at my younger sister—the girl who had been handed every advantage while I worked midnight shifts to pay my own tuition—and realized I felt no satisfaction at all in watching her drown.
"I'm not going to give you a free pass, Victoria," I said firmly. "And I'm not going to shield Dad from the state investigators."
"I don't care about Dad's deal anymore," she said quickly. "Tell me what to do. I'll sign whatever you say."
"First," I said, reaching for my phone to dial Daniel Mercer, "you're going to sit down with my lawyers this afternoon and sign a sworn affidavit stating you were misled about the January operating agreement. Second, you're going to hand over every email or text Dad ever sent you about Harborview."
"Okay," she whispered, nodding frantically. "Okay, I'll give you my phone right now."
"And third," I added as Daniel’s line began to ring, "you're going to tell Mom that if she shows up on my doorstep crying for forgiveness, she shouldn't bother knocking."